Dr Peter Hughes: Peacocks, superyachts and the road to recovery
Smarta's resident psychology expert on why we are built to spend our way out of recession.
By Dr Peter Hughes
"It is not the strong, nor the intelligent who survive," wrote
Charles Darwin, "but those who are quickest to adapt".
We are driven to consume and to make a display of it -
we are not built to stop.
Take your average peacock. Why has he evolved to make such
extravagant displays when all it seems to do is to make him more
conspicuous - hence more vulnerable to predators? While that's
true, it ignores the perspective of the peahen. A peacock's display
is the means through which males compete with each other for female
attention. This is a game with the biggest prize of all at stake:
genetic survival.
The winners will mate and pass their genes on to future
generations, the losers won't. The more ostentatious the display,
the more attractive it is to the peahen. After all, to take such
risks and survive means a peacock's genes must be very strong and
the peahen can feel confident that that her offspring who have
these genes will have a greater chance of passing them on to future
generations.
This classic example of male mating behaviour shows why Freud
got it so wrong when he attributed penis envy, the preserve of the
defeated male, to women - size and status is the means through
which men fight for the right to mate and in the world of peacocks,
the currency of male power is the plume.
In human terms, think about men who buy products at the top end of
the luxury market. A superyacht, for instance. We are accustomed to
seeing it as wasteful. Nothing could be further from the truth.
Like the peacock's tail, it's a giant advertisement: despite the
competition of countless other men and the risks to personal
safety, the big boat owner has won his breeding rights. That's why
in a typical superyacht ad there will be an average of three young,
scantily clad young women to one middle aged man.
It is in this behaviour that we can see the biological basis of
hope when economic times get tough. We are driven to consume and to
make a display of it. We are not built to stop. Of course, we can
hesitate, falter, even delay consumption for a time - but we cannot
stop. Part of the reason for this is that the typical brain has
about 30% more circuits for stimulating desire than for liking and
accepting what we've got. Consumption and growth are necessary in
evolutionary terms, which is why the worst thing a business can do
in the current climate is to believe human nature has suddenly
changed and the end of the world is nigh. Adaptation is what is
important and the fearless - those not driven to distraction by
anxiety about the future - will emerge from the recession stronger
than before.
The Great Depression, with its 15,000 bank failures and 25%
unemployment in the US, saw the emergence of world-leading brands
like Kraft, La-Z-Boy, HP and The New York Times. What made these
companies resilient in the face of rapid, destructive change is
exactly what gives individuals the power to adapt and survive while
others die - the ability to hold their nerve, be flexible in their
behaviour and to create new, imaginative displays to get themselves
noticed.